CURRENT CHEESE FLAVORS
Delight in the cozy flavors of creamy white cheddar blended with all-natural apple preserves and the warm spices of a classic apple pie. This irresistible cheese spread is perfect for adding a sweet-savory twist to your morning toast or bagel.
For a delicious snack, try pairing it with cinnamon pita chips to enjoy the perfect balance of creamy, fruity, and spiced flavors. Made with quality ingredients, it’s a versatile treat that captures the essence of fall any time of year.
3.5oz $7.95
5.5oz $9.95
7.5oz $11.95
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival to keep its fresh, smooth texture and rich taste.
Experience our newest delicious creation: a dip that captures everything you love about baked Brie! We start with creamy, gooey Brie cheese, blended with locally sourced Jersey honey and crushed pistachios for a perfect sweet and nutty flavor.
Topped with a delightful pistachio and puff pastry crumble and a generous dollop of our rich fig jam, this dip offers an irresistible combination of textures and tastes. Simply serve with crunchy bread or crackers for the ultimate treat.
Perfect for entertaining or a luxurious snack that will wow your guests!
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Creamy white cheddar blended with a sweet caramelized onion jam, whole grain mustard, and savory spices. It’s finished with a beer reduction made with a local Jersey Blonde Ale by Zed’s Brewery.
This beer cheese is creamy, bold, and made for summer. Great dip for pretzels or spread it on burgers, sandwiches, or add it to your next charcuterie board.
Available sizes:
3.5oz jar $7.95, 5.5oz jar $9.95, and 7.5oz jar $11.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Indulge in the rich, sophisticated blend of our aged sharp cheddar combined with a velvety port wine reduction crafted from Valnezano Winery’s locally produced Jersey Devil Port Wine.
This exquisite cheese spread perfectly balances the bold, tangy sharpness of aged cheddar with the deep, fruity sweetness of the port wine, creating a harmonious flavor that delights the palate.
As one of our best-selling wine-inspired spreads, it’s a customer favorite for good reason—ideal for enhancing cheese boards, pairing with artisan crackers, or adding a gourmet twist to your appetizers. Made with premium, locally sourced ingredients, this spread offers a memorable taste experience that’s perfect for entertaining or indulging at home.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Available only in September and October, our fan-favorite Oktoberfest cheese spread is back by popular demand!
This sharp cheddar is expertly blended with whole grain mustard and locally brewed Marzen Hungarian Lager from Zed’s Brewery in New Jersey. The Marzen lager, a traditional German beer brewed in March and enjoyed during Oktoberfest, adds a unique, rich depth to this seasonal spread. Perfectly paired with fresh-baked soft pretzels, it also shines in our signature Mac & Cheese—be sure to check availability on our Mac & Cheese page.
Don’t miss out on this limited-time flavor that captures the spirit of fall celebrations.
3.5oz $7.95
5.5oz $9.95
7.5oz $11.95
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Indulge in the rich, creamy flavor of our signature white cheddar cheese spread, expertly blended with locally roasted, salted pistachios for a perfect balance of savory and nutty notes. This beloved cheese spread is a customer favorite.
Crafted with premium, locally sourced ingredients to ensure the freshest, most authentic taste. Perfect for snacking, entertaining, or elevating any cheese board. Refrigerate immediately upon arrival to maintain its smooth texture and delightful flavor.
Enjoy the timeless taste that keeps our customers coming back for more!
REFRIGERATE IMMEDIATELY UPON ARRIVAL.
Enjoy all the classic flavors of sweet Italian cannoli’s transformed into a creamy dip!
This delicious blend combines smooth mascarpone and ricotta cheeses, lightly sweetened and studded with mini chocolate chips for that authentic cannoli taste. And then topped with crumbled cannoli chips.
Perfect for parties, it pairs wonderfully with cannoli chips, but it’s also fantastic as a crepe filling or a topping for pancakes. Create a decadent dessert board by serving it with waffle cone pieces, graham crackers, and fresh strawberries.
Available in a 7.5oz tub for convenient entertaining.
Keep refrigerated
American Lager Cheese is back in stock! A bold, savory cheddar spread made with American Lager (by Kinds Road Brewery), roasted garlic & onion jam, and a rich beer reduction for an extra boost of malty flavor. Scoop it up with crunchy pretzel crisps for the ultimate beer & cheese bite.
Available sizes:
3.5oz jar $7.95, 5.5oz jar $9.95, and 7.5oz jar $11.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Savor the bold flavors of our white sharp cheddar blended with aromatic garlic and a medley of classic Italian herbs. This versatile cheese spread is perfect for adding a savory kick to your favorite dishes.
Try schmearing it on a crusty loaf of bread and melting it gently in the oven to create irresistible homemade garlic bread bursting with rich, herby goodness.
Made with premium ingredients, this spread is a must-have for quick snacks, appetizers, or enhancing your meals.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
If you love buffalo wings, you’ll adore this cheese spread! It combines sharp cheddar and mild blue cheese blended with the classic buffalo wing sauce flavor for a creamy, tangy, and slightly spicy treat.
Perfect for spreading on crackers, adding to sandwiches, or serving as a flavorful dip.
Available in multiple sizes—refrigerate immediately upon arrival to keep its fresh, bold taste.
Introducing ‘Sweet Fire!’—a bold and flavorful cheese spread where sharp cheddar is blended with a rich beer reduction made from Tonewood Brewery’s locally crafted Fuego beer.
This unique blend is then balanced with sweet honey, tangy mustard, and a spicy kick of sriracha for a perfect combination of heat and sweetness. Ideal for adding excitement to sandwiches, snacks, or cheese boards.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Discover the bold, savory blend of sharp white cheddar combined with creamy horseradish, all-natural bacon bits, and locally crafted Yards Brawler Beer from Yard's Brewery. This fan-favorite beer-infused cheese spread delivers a perfect balance of smoky, tangy, and rich flavors, making it one of our best-selling varieties.
Perfect for adding a gourmet touch to snacks, sandwiches, or your favorite crackers.
REFRIGERATE IMMEDIATELY UPON ARRIVAL.
Savor the rich flavor of aged cheddar blended with chives and real, all-natural bacon bits—completely free of nitrates.
This savory spread adds a delicious smoky and herbaceous twist that’s perfect melted on your next burger for an irresistible upgrade. Crafted with quality ingredients for a bold, satisfying taste.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival
Indulge in the sweet and creamy blend of our house-made peach jam, crafted with Jersey Fresh peaches, that is swirled into smooth white cheddar cheese.
This delightful spread is perfectly finished with a splash of Jersey Peach Wine from William Heritage Winery, infusing it with vibrant peachy notes that celebrate the best of local flavors.
Ideal for enhancing cheese boards, pairing with crackers, or adding a fruity twist to your snacks.
Available sizes:
3.5oz jar $7.95, 5.5oz jar $9.95, and 7.5oz jar $11.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Experience the bold flavors of our white sharp cheddar blended with a classic Sicilian blend of fragrant herbs, savory garlic, and a subtle kick of crushed red pepper.
This unique combination delivers a perfect balance of savory, spicy, and aromatic notes that elevate any snack or recipe. Spread it on crusty bread, add it to sandwiches, or enjoy straight from the jar for a flavorful treat.
Made with high-quality ingredients, this cheese spread is a must-have for lovers of authentic Mediterranean flavors.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
This delightful spread blends our sweet fig & orange jam with creamy, tangy goat cheese for a light and slightly sweet flavor.
It’s a perfect addition to your cheese boards or a delicious alternative to butter on warm, toasty bread—ideal for elevating your breakfast toast.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
A savory blend of hickory smoked gouda and cheddar cheese.
We use this spread to make our Smoked Gouda Mac & Cheese. One of our best selling flavors! Check out our Mac & Cheese page to see if we have some available. It’s a must try sometime!
Available sizes:
3.50oz jar $7.95, 5.5oz jar $9.95, and 7.75oz jar $11.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
A creamy white cheddar that we mix with all natural pure pumpkin and all those classic Fall spices. Yum! This rolls out the first day of Fall! And then we’ll make it right through the holiday season.
Another good one to try on that morning bagel. Great for snacking with graham crackers, especially cinnamon ones!
Available sizes:
3.5oz jar $7.95 5.5oz jar $9.95 and 7.5oz jar $11.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Delight in the luxurious blend of creamy gorgonzola cheese mixed with sweet figs and luscious fig preserves, perfectly finished with a rich swirl of balsamic reduction.
This sophisticated spread offers a harmonious balance of tangy, sweet, and savory flavors, making it a standout favorite at farmers’ markets. Ideal for elevating cheese boards or adding a gourmet touch to your appetizers.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Enjoy the perfect balance of sharp cheddar cheese blended with creamy horseradish for a flavorful spread with just the right amount of gentle heat—enough to excite your taste buds without overwhelming them.
This versatile cheese spread melts beautifully, making it an ideal addition to roast beef sandwiches, whether served hot or cold.
Crafted with quality ingredients for a smooth, rich texture, it’s a delicious way to elevate your everyday meals.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
A SNEAK PEEK AT WHAT’S COMING SOON!
Creamy white cheddar blended with roasted walnuts and sweetened with cranberries. We roll this flavor out just in time for Thanksgiving and it stays with us right through the end of the year!
Perfect as a sandwich spread on turkey sandwiches!
Available sizes:
3.5oz jar $6.95, 5.5oz jar $8.95, and 7.5oz jar $10.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
Tangy goat cheese is mixed with sweet New Jersey local ‘ginger’ honey and then we tossed in some ginger honey roasted almonds, which we make in house too! Yum!
Available sizes:
4oz jar $6.50, 6oz jar $8.50
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate upon arrival.
A blend of hickory smoked gouda and cheddar cheese is mixed with a Jersey local Dublin style porter from Zed’s Brewery's.
A Fall/Winter flavor
Available sizes:
3.5 oz jar $6.95, 5.5 oz jar $8.95, and 7.5 oz jar $10.95
Select size to see current stock available.
Refrigerate immediately upon arrival.
CHEESE SPREADS
Filters
No results found
No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.